If You Love Brian Cowen So Much… Why Don’t You Go Live There?

The Irish Times – Letters

Our Taoiseach has won serious respect internationally. We may not agree with some of his policies or actions. As our democratically elected leader, however, he is entitled, at least, to our respect.

Ah now.

What is democracy anyway? Is it something whose properties each citizen gets to decide on according to his or her own special interpretation? Maybe it is, and maybe every single word in the language is like a tennis ball pinged off each citizen’s head, acquiring a different spin, velocity and impact depending on the shape of that citizen’s head. What you are reading right now in these lines I write, depending on how you came to it, may be the instructions for how to land a Harrier Jump Jet or the final element required to unlock the secret code of the Bible. It’s all to play for.

My hermit-like existence, however, has forced me to stick quite unjustifiably to some relatively fixed meanings for a whole range of words, among which ‘democracy’ -along with milk, sugar, and vice grips- is but one. This may be scandalously anti-progress of me, but you can’t teach an old dog new tricks. In my troglodyte’s lexicon, democracy means rule by the people. And that means that the people confer certain other people, who are their equal, with power to do things on their behalf. So if democracy is rule by the people, and Brian Cowen is Taoiseach, this is because the people have decided that he is the one to do the job (outrageously, some clowns might cavil and kvetch at this immaculate syllogism). With democracy, therefore, it cannot be the case that Brian Cowen is entitled to the people’s respect as our leader, because for him to be respected simply on account of this would be tantamount to saying ‘this person, who is our equal, is not our equal’.

Now there was a woman on Liveline yesterday, and she said that the President was Ireland the nation in corporeal form. In some awful places, such delusional declarations would be enough to get you locked up on grounds of mental health. Fortunately, we live in a democracy in which the minister for mental health is also a publican, and such declarations are positively encouraged. My fear, and I am fairly confident that this is not a delusion, is that both the ideas that Brian Cowen deserves respect because why, he’s our leader goddammit and that Mary McAleese is Ireland would not be considered outrageous by a significant number among the population. This sort of thing, I fear, augurs badly for the future of my own pet meaning of the word ‘democracy’. Perhaps the moment will come when holding to that meaning so fastly will be analogous to holding to the meaning of ‘consumption’ as a disease when everyone else deems it to mean a vital concept in the description of objective economic processes.

Advertisements

3 Responses to “If You Love Brian Cowen So Much… Why Don’t You Go Live There?”


  1. 1 David August 24, 2010 at 12:44 pm

    Maybe there should be another check on the ballot paper for the guy or girl that may or may not take over in the event that the nominated person is embarrassed out of office.

    At least if we’re gonna be coerced by liveline into trusting a ‘leader’ it should at least be on the back of some sort of sham elections anyway, not simply by party divinity.

    Isn’t there a pop culture reference I can’t remember that goes something like… [crowd chanting jubilantly] “Default! Default! Default!”

  2. 2 itsapoliticalworld August 27, 2010 at 4:01 pm

    I’ve been reading a little bit about Brian’s summer. A deeply unimpressive and unprepared speech in New York, a round of golf or two and a habitual family holiday in the west, a speech at the Tullamore Show, a match and a fag at Croke park.

    He sees the Dail as a hostile ground, not a parliamentary chamber and when he speaks there the words come out in a rush as he fumbles over the preprepared written script. It’s often clear when he speaks that not only did he not write the speech, but he didn’t bother to read it in advance of public delivery and that sometimes he misuderstands what he’s saying.

    All through the summer, as in 2008, Ireland’s financial position has been unravelling in full view. In 2008, there was no sign of life from Brian Cowen until the end of the normal round of his summer activities.

    There was a phase two years ago in which people were calling for Cowen to speak to the Nation via tv and gather us up into some kind of collective who could turn our resources into dealing with the shit storm that he and his friends have brought down on our heads. Eventually, we learned that that wss just not going to happen. There is no collective us, there are the bondholders and the political middlemen who serve their interests, and then there are the rest of us.

    Bond spreads are widening and broke records this afternoon and Brian Cowen is recovering from the opening of Ballyconneely golf course.


  1. 1 Irish democracy : Twenty Major – Still smoking in Dublin bars Trackback on August 24, 2010 at 8:55 am

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s




I on Twitter

August 2010
M T W T F S S
« Jul   Sep »
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
3031  

%d bloggers like this: